Jeff,
Depending on how aggressive you want to be, I’d look into buying the second at a discount and having a conversation with the current owner. This gives you leverage.
If you could get the second for about $20k, you’d owe $140k on a house worth approx. $250k and it may need some work to put back on the market if the current owner is not willing to give you a deed in lieu or ??
When you own the second (at a discount) you could have your own “short-sale”.
And in a hot market, it would sell quickly.
You’d get the difference between the amount owed on the second ($50k) and what you paid for it.
The owner would get the equity above the loans.
Don’t have $20k on you, I do.
Or someone else close to you.
You don’t want to make a loan to a homeowner who’s shown they don’t make their payments. You don’t want to make loans to homeowners anyway, its a trap. Ask me how I know.
You could even split the deal with the current owner.
Depending on the rehab costs, you have a nice deal here.
Deal math:
ARV: $250k
Equity: Currently $250k – $140k -$50k = $60k
Possible equity after restructure: $250k – $140k = $110k after buying the second for $20k.
Owning a second mortgage with lots of equity above you gives you lots of options.
Hope this helps,
Mike